An Israeli music producer has sued Travis Scott, Don Toliver and other collaborators in the hip-hop collective JACKBOYS, alleging he is owed master royalties for a beat sampled on their 2019 track “What To Do?”.
Background on the track#
“What To Do?” was one of seven songs on the group’s self-titled 2019 album, JACKBOYS, which debuted at No. 1 on the Billboard 200 chart. A second chart-topping set, JACKBOYS 2, followed last summer.
The song charted at No. 56 on the Billboard Hot 100 and No. 20 on the Hot Rap Songs chart.
The sample dispute#
Niv Kalisky, who records as “Early Yellow,” filed the lawsuit on Tuesday (Nov. 17) against the JACKBOYS team. The complaint alleges that Kalisky has not received the master royalties he is due for a sample used by the group’s artists, who are signed to his label, Cactus Jack Records.
Kalisky is credited as a songwriter and additional producer on “What To Do?”, which entitles him to publishing income from the composition. The lawsuit argues that he is also owed master royalties, because he supplied a sample beat to the track’s producers and it was later mixed into the final sound recording.
According to the complaint, Kalisky’s lawyers sent several royalty requests over the years to Cactus Jack and its distribution partner, Sony’s Epic Records, without success. Kalisky’s team also filed takedown requests for the song with Spotify, Apple Music and other digital streaming services. The complaint alleges that Sony countered those requests with counter-notices to the streaming platforms.
The lawsuit states: “It is clear that the Defendants had actual knowledge that the Plaintiff had received zero compensation for the usage of the sound recording contained in the registered sample,” adding that the defendants repeatedly said they would resolve the matter but made no good-faith effort to do so.
Claims and relief sought#
Kalisky is bringing copyright infringement claims against the following parties:
- Cactus Jack Records
- Sony
- Travis Scott
- Don Toliver
- Sheck Wes, a fellow JACKBOYS member
- Various producers who worked on “What To Do?”
He is seeking a share of the track’s “substantial” recording revenue, including income from album sales, streaming and sync licensing.
Kalisky’s lawyers, Justin M. Jacobson and Daniel Cruz Hernandez, said on Tuesday: “Producers are becoming more aware of their rights, and today our client chose to stand up for what he deserves.”
Representatives for the defendants had not responded to requests for comment on the lawsuit.
