YouTube removed musician Samantha Shokin’s recording of the traditional Bulgarian folk song “Bre Petrunko” after a copyright complaint from a company she had never heard of, then restored it about 24 hours later. The case centers on how copyright claims apply to a folk song with no known writer.
Removal and reinstatement#
Shokin recorded herself singing an approximately 50-second a cappella version of “Bre Petrunko,” a 19th-century song described as having no known writer. She uploaded it to YouTube, where it gathered around 125,000 views over four years.
In October, YouTube removed the video following a copyright complaint from Media Nov Records, a company Shokin had never heard of before.
YouTube restored the video about 24 hours later. A spokesperson for Media Nov confirmed that the company withdrew the complaint minutes after Shokin provided the necessary verification.
Media Nov said the reason for withdrawing was that the video had generated no revenue or views. That claim conflicts with the video’s view count of approximately 125,000.
Who filed the complaint#
- Media Nov Records describes itself as a music distribution and rights management company.
- It operates approximately 500 YouTube channels, which appeared to contain mostly repetitive electronic music and artificial intelligence (AI) generated imagery.
- Its website refers to automated Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) takedowns, YouTube Content ID management and AI-powered content recognition.
- Records indicate the company is a little over a year old, although its website suggests a longer history.
Questions over rights in the song#
The song is described as having no known writer, but the status of particular arrangements may differ by version and jurisdiction. Musician Philip Koutev popularized a specific arrangement of the song in 1963.
Media Nov argued that rights in that arrangement must be distinguished from rights in any individual sound recording.
Reactions and legal view#
“It’s ironic that they’re in the copyright business,” said Shokin. “It’s not the arrangement that’s in question; it’s the voice and performance. They clearly have no clue what they’re talking about.”
Artist and copyright lawyer Alfred Steiner said: “That makes it really ridiculous. If it’s her voice and her playing instruments, what could she possibly be infringing if it’s a folk song from the 19th century?”
Shokin also said: “It sounds like they got scared and feel like this is not a battle worth fighting.”
Steiner explained the liability risks of such requests:
“Submitting a takedown request for rights that you don’t have can subject you to liability, which includes actual damages and costs and attorney’s fees,” Steiner explained. “Doing this on a slipshod, shotgun approach is inadvisable from my perspective. Of course, if all of the people you end up offending are small parties and don’t have the resources to respond through the court system, and you are a fly-by-night entity that is hard to pin down and nobody knows who you are, […] it can be difficult to get a remedy.”
Shokin said she felt vindicated but frustrated that the company responded only after she reached out to a journalist. “They got my emails […] and they were just ignoring it,” Shokin said. “They only decided to respond because they got scared that it’ll be bad press. It’s just not great all around. The whole system is broken. It feels like a broken system.”
