The National Music Publishers’ Association (NMPA) and the Nashville Songwriters Association International (NSAI) have again moved to subpoena the Mechanical Licensing Collective (MLC) in the U.S. Phono V royalty proceeding. The motion follows rate proposals that leading digital service providers (DSPs) submitted last month.
Phono V will set statutory mechanical royalty rates for on-demand streaming in the U.S. from 2028 through 2032.
Competing Phono V rate proposals#
Parties on the opposing side of the proceeding have objected to the DSP proposals. The Songwriters Guild of America, Word Collections and others are seeking a simplified flat-rate mechanical royalty.
- Spotify proposed a continued 15.35% headline rate of applicable service provider revenue and “no other changes” from Phono IV.
- Amazon Music, which is owned by Amazon, suggested a 13.4% headline percentage for 2028 through 2032.
Spotify defended the Phono IV settlement, including its bundling terms, which have drawn heavy criticism. The company called the settlement “a success for the industry” and said the “bundle terms and economics in particular were a known, core term of the Phonorecords IV settlement.”
Amazon Music attributed its position in part to music publishers’ response to bundling, which it said “robbed Amazon of a key benefit it expected to gain from the Phonorecords IV settlement.” The platform also seeks to remove the revenue prong from bundled subscription calculations.
The MLC’s lawsuit against Spotify#
The MLC has sued Spotify over the company’s unilateral reclassification of audiobook-music bundles. The case has continued alongside the Phono V proceeding despite setbacks for the MLC, and fact discovery is currently wrapping up.
Because the suit concerns those bundle reclassifications, its findings may be relevant to Phono V.
The renewed subpoena request#
The CRB judges had denied an earlier subpoena request before the rate proposals were filed. If granted, the new subpoena would compel the MLC to produce “[a]ll documents produced or exchanged in the Part 385 Litigation concerning the MLC’s claim that Spotify misreported and underpaid mechanical royalties owed.”
Spotify does not appear to support producing the documents. According to the NMPA, a subpoena is required “to obtain restricted documents in that action” because of the MLC v. Spotify protective order. That order states, in part: “Nothing herein shall preclude the parties from disclosing material designated to be Confidential Information if otherwise required by law or pursuant to a valid subpoena.”
Arguments over document production#
The movants argued that “Spotify is exploiting the abbreviated timeline of this proceeding to suppress production” and that “[t]here is no practical means to timely obtain the documents other than by subpoena.”
The NMPA said the documents “are highly relevant to a central issue in this proceeding,” as they “address a dispute over actual practices by services that massively reduced mechanical royalties through their interpretation of core terms and definitions at issue here.”
The NMPA also acknowledged that Spotify itself could be compelled to produce the documents. It argued that, “given Spotify’s efforts to suppress production, it should be clear that it must produce all documents produced or exchanged by any party or nonparty in the” MLC litigation. “Anything less would enable Spotify to unilaterally decide what to produce, and Spotify has already shown it deems plainly relevant documents to be not relevant.”
Last month, Chief Copyright Royalty Judge Trevor Jefferson granted DSPs access to unredacted Web VI materials in the Phono V proceeding.
