Wixen has partially dismissed the second amended complaint that music publisher Wixen filed against Meta, the owner of Instagram. The ruling allows the remaining infringement, trade libel and defamation claims to proceed.
The partial dismissal came in a brief order after Meta moved in October to dismiss the second amended complaint.
How the dispute began#
The case centers on a licensing agreement that soured. Wixen alleged that Meta made a renewal offer that would have resulted in “drastically” reduced songwriter royalties.
The plaintiff also alleged that the proposal aimed to replace music with artificial intelligence (AI) output: “to replace human-generated, royalty-bearing music with royalty-free AI-generated music.”
When affected professionals asked why their works had been taken down, Meta allegedly blamed Wixen, which allegedly lost clients as a result of the alleged defamation.
The amended complaint#
The original case was dismissed without prejudice in September, with the expectation that Wixen would refile. The publisher quickly filed an updated complaint alleging infringement of 569 works, down from 681 in the previous filing.
The updated complaint includes the following allegations:
- Copyright infringement, alleging that “thousands” of users’ Reels incorporated the works after the licensing deal expired
- Trade libel and defamation, alleging that Meta blamed Wixen for the takedowns and that Wixen lost clients as a result
- Reduced songwriter royalties tied to the renewal offer
Court ruling on standing and remaining claims#
Judge Walter wrote: “Under the 1909 [Copyright] Act, copyright interests were traditionally treated as indivisible, such that an exclusive licensee ‘may not alone maintain an infringement action’ without joining the ‘copyright owner.’”
Because those owners are not plaintiffs, “Wixen lacks standing to assert its copyright infringement claims with respect to” the pre-1978 works at issue, the judge ruled.
The court allowed the remainder of the claims to proceed, including the infringement counts and the trade libel and defamation allegations. Meta’s other dismissal arguments “are more appropriately resolved on a motion for summary judgment,” Judge Walter indicated.
Related cases#
Separately, the suit brought by Epidemic Sound against Meta, which began in 2022, is ongoing. Eight Mile Style, the publisher of Eminem, has also filed a more recent infringement suit that is proceeding.
