Skip to content

Music news, business and culture.

Join Newsletter

IMPALA’s Helen Smith Urges Action Against Streaming Fraud

IMPALA's Helen Smith calls for coordinated action against streaming fraud and AI-generated content, citing a recent royalties case.

Helen Smith, Executive Chair of IMPALA

IMPALA (Independent Music Companies Association) has set out a Digital Music Plan calling on platforms, distributors, rightsholders and trade associations to coordinate action across the music value chain. The plan responds to growing streaming manipulation and fraud, which generative artificial intelligence (AI) has made easier by allowing content to be created and mass-uploaded, including what is described as “so-called AI slop.”

Why fraud matters to the industry#

Helen Smith, IMPALA’s Executive Chair, wrote: “The consequences of fraud go beyond distorted figures.” She said streaming manipulation exploits remuneration and recommendation systems, diverts revenues away from legitimate artists and labels, and undermines trust in streaming. “Ultimately, it’s the integrity of the digital music market that is at stake.”

Smith also framed the issue as one of fair competition. Independent music companies often have more limited resources to monitor and respond to fraudulent activity, which leaves them particularly exposed and disproportionately affected. She argued that action must be taken at the right level to prevent fraud in the first place.

Industry cooperation and voluntary measures#

Smith said tackling these challenges requires more than identifying fraud after the damage is done. IMPALA is a partner in the industry-wide Streaming Integrity Initiative (SII), launched earlier this year with the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry (IFPI) and others.

IMPALA also signed a pan-industry voluntary code of best practice, together with other music industry representatives and streaming services, a few years ago. Smith said the current momentum around streaming integrity offers a chance to work together to update that code.

Measures IMPALA says are needed#

Smith listed the following actions:

  • Tougher artist verification
  • Robust KYC (know your customer) and fraud prevention systems
  • Effective detection of fake accounts and artificial streaming
  • Targeted financial measures that deter persistent offenders, such as carriage fees and penalties

Distributors also have a responsibility to verify their clients and content before delivery systems are used.

AI-generated content#

Smith said a further priority is establishing clear and consistent approaches to AI-generated content. She said AI tools can help improve fraud detection, business efficiencies and creative processes, and that responsible AI features are being developed for artists and fans. These features are welcome where artists and labels choose to take part.

She also pointed to new risks, including the mass uploading of materially AI-generated content and manipulation of plays. Smith said this helps fraudsters shift value away from genuine artists and rights owners and increases the climate impact of digital services.

The Michael Smith case#

Smith cited the recent case of Michael Smith, who was found to have fraudulently obtained over $8 million in royalties. The case shows how AI-generated content and artificial streaming can be combined to manipulate the system. It prompts several questions:

  • How many other fraudsters are gaming the system?
  • How much revenue has been taken away from genuine artists and rights owners?
  • What is the climate impact?

Other priorities in the plan#

The plan also identifies priorities beyond fraud that it says could be transformative for the entire market. Examples include:

  • Increasing subscription prices and making sure music is included in all price increases, especially where other services are bundled in
  • Querying whether all repertoire delivery obligations should apply to music that is unlikely to be monetized
  • Measuring value gaps as an industry
  • Challenging payment models outside streaming, such as the creator economy
  • Adding new payment boosts for new releases and diverse repertoire

Concluding her remarks, Smith said: “One thing is certain: trust and integrity are ecosystem-wide challenges, and there is no single solution to address them.” She added: “Progress depends on ambition, experimentation, and collaboration across the industry, as we say in our digital music plan. Let’s continue working together to protect artists, fans, and the integrity of the digital music market.”

Sponsored

ToneGrid: deliver your music globally. White-label distribution, royalties and analytics for labels and distributors.

More like this

Pick your tempo

Who owns what, who got paid, and who is about to. The business behind African music, told like it is actually interesting (because it is).

  • The deals and catalogue sales nobody put out a press release for
  • Chart moves and streaming numbers we actually fact-checked (wild, we know)
  • Fresh names added to the directory, vetted before you ever see them

Free forever Ghost us anytime, one click

Get the inside track from Afrobeats Wire

Choose your speed. We will handle the rest.

How fast do you want it?

Your inbox is sacred. This address is used for the newsletter and nothing else, never sold, never passed on. Privacy policy.